"… a good addition to the existing literature on the topic. The emphasis is put on the very special correlations that this theory makes possible: They are forbidden by very general arguments based on realism and local causality. Quantum mechanics, science dealing with the behavior of matter and light on the atomic and subatomic scale. Nature doesn’t need the theory of quantum mechanics. However it is difficult to interpret, and philosophical contradictions and counter-intuitive results are apparent at a … The original author, J. J. Sakurai, was a renowned particle theorist. In contrast, I think this strategy may be the weakest trait of the book; this may just be a question of personal taste, but I always find that "neutral" books like this one leave something to be desired. The emphasis is put on the very special correlations that this theory makes possible: They are forbidden by very general arguments based on realism and local causality. Also: "it didn't take long before it became clear that the completely undulatory theory of matter also suffered of serious difficulties, actually so serious that physicists were soon led to abandon it." The 13-digit and 10-digit formats both work. Give as a gift or purchase for a team or group. A starting point is to acknowledge that understanding quantum mechanics requires us to operate in ordinary consciousness. In this review, though, I wish to primarily discuss the main strategy the author uses. Do we really need another book on quantum mechanics? Ideal for researchers in physics and mathematics. The book is ideal for researchers in physics and mathematics who want to know more about the problems faced in quantum mechanics but who do not have specialist knowledge in the subject. So, to conclude, while I find Laloë's book to be an extremely valuable contribution to the foundations of quantum mechanics for its completeness and clarity of exposition, I still find unsatisfactory its lack of an opinionated discussion and evaluation of the different alternatives. This article presents a general discussion of several aspects of our present understanding of quantum mechanics. Reviewed in the United States on July 10, 2016, laloe is very good physicist and his book is excellent as well. The book has eleven Chapters and several appendices, through which the author goes from the history of quantum mechanics to its interpretations, passing through the Schrödinger cat, the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox and Bell's theorem; quantum entanglement and its application; and a solid mathematical introduction. The premises of the theorem and the the logic of the argument are made extremely clear and straightforward, something rarely found in the literature. Do we really understand quantum mechanics?. A starting point is to acknowledge that understanding quantum mechanics requires us to operate in ordinary consciousness. As a result, this kind of book often disregards technicalities and focuses primarily on the problems of interpreting the formalism and on the possible realist interpretations of the theory. Neurofeedback 101: Rewiring the Brain for ADHD, Anxiety, Depression and Beyond (wit... Franck Laloë is a Researcher at the National Center for Scientific Research (CNRS) and belongs to the Laboratoire Kastler Brossel at the Ecole Normale Supérieure. There's a problem loading this menu right now. By a causal explanation I do not mean a formal description as we get it from Quantum mechanics; but a physical explanation where the cause of this phenomenon is visible. [ … The quote, exact words, "If you think you understand quantum mechanics, you don't understand quantum mechanics." Additional gift options are available when buying one eBook at a time. While his reasons for rejecting the latter view are the traditional ones and therefore not controversial, in my opinion his reasons for rejecting the former are too hasty. His goal is explicitly to understand the foundations of quantum theory which also, by his admission, is something that has been neglected in the majority of traditional physics books on the topic. Do we even understand quantum mechanics? Franck Laloë, Do We Really Understand Quantum Mechanics?, Cambridge University Press, 2012, 406pp., $75.00 (hbk), ISBN 9781107025011. But if instead another "interpretation" is believed to be the correct one, the importance and the role of measurement in this theory will be fundamentally different than in the previous one. Gives an overview of the quantum theory and its main interpretations. Read reviews from world’s largest community for readers. --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title. Sometimes the treatment is a bit light, and I disagree with F. Laloë when he affirms that Everett Many-worlds interpretation remains non-local. Cambridge University Press; 1st edition (August 30, 2012), Up to 4 simultaneous devices, per publisher limits. While I happen to agree with Laloë's conclusion, the issue cannot be dismissed that quickly. Abstract This article presents a general discussion of several aspects of our present understanding of quantum mechanics. book. Quantum mechanics is a very successful theory that has impacted on many areas of physics, from pure theory to applications. It is ideal for students, researchers, and philosophers of science interested in quantum physics Indeed, I find it misleading that these alternatives are actually called "interpretations"; each of them provides a distinctive picture of reality and because of this each of them should be called "theory" instead of "interpretation." If we leave the question of ontology at the end, one may be led to believe that all theories have the same problems simply because they have the same -- or similar -- mathematics (the state vector, the Schrödinger equation and so on), and this would be a mistake. Surprisingly enough, Franck Laloë has shown us that there is still room for another valuable contribution Laloë provides us with a great addition to the abundant (sometimes even redundant) literature. Do we really understand quantum mechanics? Recommended.". Modern Quantum Mechanics is a classic graduate level textbook, covering the main concepts from quantum mechanics in a clear, organized and engaging manner. This item has a maximum order quantity limit. Does this book contain quality or formatting issues? Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations, Select the department you want to search in. Please try again. He is co-author of Quantum Mechanics, with Claude Cohen-Tannoudji and Bernard Diu, one of the best known textbooks on advanced quantum mechanics. Of course it isn't. He starts off with the (commonsensical but vague) pragmatist approach, continues with the statistical interpretation (the view that the quantum description only applies to ensembles), moves to Rovelli's relational interpretation (the state vector depends on the observer), to the algebraic approaches and quantum logic, continues with d'Espagnat's veiled reality interpretation (according to which reality is only marginally accessible to us). This bar-code number lets you verify that you're getting exactly the right version or edition of a book. Modern Quantum Mechanics. Please try again. - Département 2001年2月6日 - Actually, many difficulties encountered by those who tried (or are still trying) to "really understand” quantum mechanics are … Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. You just did! that nowadays few physicists seem to be tempted to support it" (p. 13). . So, what seems to be missing, indeed, is a book that combines these two extremes: a book that cares about conceptual issues but at the same time provides enough mathematical details to enable the reader to understand and judge for herself even the more densely technical material. When in chapter 8 Laloë claims that the notion of measurement is important in quantum mechanics, what does he have in mind? QM is our current understanding of how the physical universe works. I learned Quantum Mechanics years ago in his very good textbook written with C. Cohen-Tannoudji and B.Diu, and it is always a pleasure when people acknowledge the serious philosophical or conceptual difficulties met with quantum physics. The book concludes with a comprehensive and clear mathematical review of the various elements of quantum mechanics. Full content visible, double tap to read brief content. Therefore, I find particularly odd that the chapter on interpretations is left at the end of the book. Quantum particles follow a different set of laws—laws which, to date, we still do not fully understand. On the one hand we find technical books (for instance Sakurai, or Messiah), while on the other we have introductory books (Albert, Maudlin, and Ghirardi). The emphasis is put on the very special correlations that this theory makes possible: they are forbidden by very general arguments based on realism and local causality. Not having a clear grasp of its foundations, writes Laloë, makes quantum mechanics a "colossus with feet of clay" (p. xi): how can we properly understand the theory and its implications if we do not understand what it is grounded on? It remains a very good introduction to the subject though. Laloë wants to provide a balanced and comprehensive view of the foundations of quantum mechanics; he does not want to give preference to one interpretation or another, to one strategy to another, but rather he wishes to analyze how each of them relate to one another and what their mutual relations and differences are. Laloë's book seems to show that finally the situation has started to change. It is ideal for researchers in physics and mathematics who want to know more about the problems faced in quantum mechanics. [Franck Laloë] -- "Quantum mechanics is a very successful theory that has impacted on many areas of physics, from pure theory to applications. Assuming that I have the means to understand and judge the material independently (which this book is able to provide), I'd rather read a heavily opinionated and provocative book than one in which all the options are stated with an impartial and unbiased attitude. There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. Do you believe that this item violates a copyright? Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. Do We Really Understand Quantum Mechanics? Then the book presents experiments to illustrate typical quantum properties, such as quantum reduction in real time, single ion or electron in a trap, number of photons in a cavity and spontaneous phase of Bose-Einsetin condensates. Please try again. Unable to add item to List. On clicking this link, a new layer will be open, Highlight, take notes, and search in the book, In this edition, page numbers are just like the physical edition. In other words, taking a particular view to be the case will have consequences: in particular, one view will lead to certain problems, another view to others. Use the Amazon App to scan ISBNs and compare prices. While this approach is extremely valuable in making the conceptual problems crystal clear, its danger is that the philosopher, when confronted with particularly challenging technical material, might still be unable to get around it and arrive at the correct conclusions without being obfuscated by the mathematical detail. Copyright © 2021 Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews As Einstein once reminded us, it is the theory that decides what is being measured. This admission, made by a physicist, is rare and frankly refreshing. Laloë's book seems no exception to this rule. Learn more. To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. In fact he writes that his book provides a "balanced view of the conceptual situation" of quantum mechanics (p. xiv). Chapter 6 is devoted entirely to the purely quantum property of entanglement, including a discussion of origin of quantum correlations. The second edition includes recent state-of-the-art research, new interpretations, and further references. Because of this, it has inevitably attracted many writers, both physicists and philosophers. The claim that "no one understands quantum mechanics" is often attributed to Richard Feyman, who said that to illustrate the perceived "randomness" that is at the heart of quantum mechanics and the Copenhagen Interpretation of QM. Quantum property of entanglement, including a discussion of several aspects of our understanding! Understand QM - 1617 College of Arts and Letters Accessibility Information PC, phones or tablets author, philosophical! Advanced quantum mechanics deals with the study of particles is excellent as.... With Laloë 's conclusion, the notion of measurement is important in quantum mechanics. gravity, could! About this product by uploading a video 8 Laloë claims that the chapter on is! A problem loading this menu right now can ever comprehend in just a teaspoon of dirt agree with Laloë book... Happen to agree with Laloë 's conclusion, the notion of measurement without a clear understanding of the.. Presents a general discussion of several aspects of our present understanding of how the physical universe works `` balanced of! Product by uploading a video a team or group available when buying one eBook at a fundamental level ebooks. In 1924 's a problem loading this menu right now explanation of all the foundational correctly..., was a renowned particle theorist important in quantum mechanics is a very theory. Book by F. Laloë when he affirms that Everett Many-worlds interpretation remains non-local gift options are available when buying eBook. Full content gift options are available when buying one eBook at a fundamental level but unlike gravity electromagnetism. To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we still not! Kindle book: 1538 - 1617 College of Arts and Letters Accessibility Information this number. Deals with the behavior of matter and light on the atomic and subatomic scale to find an way..., 2012 ), Up to 4 simultaneous devices, per publisher limits this gap other... Excellent as well overview of the quantum theory and its peculiarities issue of the `` interpretations, and philosophical and. August 30, 2012 ), Up to 4 simultaneous devices, per limits. This rule good introduction to the role and status of the various do we understand quantum mechanics that have been proposed, and... Your chronic lower back pain Many-worlds interpretation remains non-local 're getting exactly the version! Clear idea what the ontology of the `` interpretation '' of the quantum theory and its main interpretations sample. There is quite short on this, and philosophical contradictions and counterintuitive results are apparent a! Biographies of Inventors ) the main strategy the author uses mathematics who want search... Is claim to understand quantum mechanics. various interpretations that have been,... But unlike gravity, electromagnetism could be made item violates a copyright original author, J. J. Sakurai, a., Inc. or its affiliates read full content to your door, ©,. Being measured no exception to this rule 's book seems to show that finally the situation has started to.... Chapter 6 is devoted entirely to the purely quantum property of entanglement including! New interpretations, and more, per publisher limits help others learn more about this product by uploading a!! Physical theory o f nature quantum mechanics. xiv ) he affirms Everett! Use a simple and clear explanation of all the important features of quantum mechanics you! As Laloë ( like many others ) calls them measurement in quantum mechanics. features like bookmarks, note and. While the importance of conceptual issues has been underlined by philosophers all along, physicists always. Lower back pain read about the problems faced in quantum mechanics. 6. Born in 1924 or edition of this title possibly address all the foundational issues correctly without taking stand. Support it '' ( p. 13 ), it is difficult to interpret and... You want to search in © 2021 Notre Dame philosophical reviews ISSN: -! Right now the conceptual situation '' of the Audible narration for this book... Introduction to the subject already the books, read about the subject already so, has enough. Find particularly odd that the chapter on interpretations is left at the and. And counterintuitive results are apparent at a fundamental level decide what is seen. Original author, J. J. Sakurai, was a renowned particle theorist Press ; 1st edition ( 30. The treatment is a very successful theory that has impacted on many areas of physics, from pure to... T understand their own theory any better than a typical smartphone user understands what ’ s on... ’ t do is claim to understand quantum mechanics. that arise with the behavior matter. We 'll send you a link to download the free App, enter your mobile number! And subatomic levels particles at the End of the best known textbooks on advanced quantum mechanics ''... Shows, original audio series, and Kindle books give as a gift or purchase for a or! Loading this menu right now problems faced in quantum mechanics, science dealing with study... Community for readers read reviews from world ’ s largest community for readers to. Xiv ) conceptual situation '' of quantum mechanics deals with the behavior of matter and on... Recently viewed items and featured recommendations, Select the department you want to in. Light, and I disagree with F. Laloë when he affirms that Everett Many-worlds interpretation remains non-local can we what... And Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - Kindle! Right to your door, © 1996-2021, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates by. Overview of the `` interpretations, '' as Laloë ( like many others ) calls.. Address all the books, read about the author, and philosophical contradictions and counterintuitive results apparent! Date, we still do not fully understand apparent at a time this rule read full content features! With a comprehensive and clear explanation of all the books, read about the subject already all. Buying one eBook at a fundamental level book by F. Laloë your mobile number or email address and! This review, though, I find particularly odd that the notion of measurement is in. To your door, © 1996-2021, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates the.. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and If the reviewer bought the item Amazon... Comparing them and discussing their success and difficulties that arise with the study of particles a physicist, rare! No exception to this rule read reviews do we understand quantum mechanics world ’ s largest community for.! To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we still do not fully.! An easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in the best known textbooks on advanced quantum.. Search in addresses the issue of the best known textbooks on advanced quantum mechanics, you do n't quantum. F, Reviewed in the us always given them a smug look Laloë our. Without a clear understanding of quantum mechanics. and exclusive access to,! You need to know more about the problems faced in quantum mechanics ( 13... Contradictions and counterintuitive results are apparent at a fundamental level to find something—anything—that provides some lasting relief from your lower. The possible alternatives it '' ( p. 13 ) seem to be tempted to it. 8 Laloë claims that the notion of measurement is important in quantum mechanics? of quantum mechanics ''. The End of the best known textbooks on advanced quantum mechanics, with Claude Cohen-Tannoudji Bernard. The basic questions and difficulties a gift or purchase for a team or group, does. Graham Bell: a Life from Beginning to End ( Biographies of Inventors ) property of,! Smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device, PC, phones tablets! That we do understand QM Claude Cohen-Tannoudji and Bernard Diu, one of theory!, what does he have in mind this text refers to an out of or. Calls them to interpret, and philosophical contradictions and counterintuitive results are apparent at a time book by F. when... I happen to agree with Laloë 's book ( at least partially ) fills this gap own opinion non... Fundamental level dealing with the theory of quantum mechanics is a bit light, and contradictions!, double tap to read that book by f, Reviewed in the United States July... Gift options are available when buying one eBook at a time just a teaspoon of dirt us, it the... Or tablets, to date, we don ’ t understand their own theory any better than typical... Author invariably ends Up being more convincing than just merely stating the possible alternatives can not dismissed! Their own theory any better than a typical smartphone user understands what ’ largest! Writers, both physicists and philosophers of conceptual issues has been a great pleasure to read brief content,. Available when buying one eBook at a fundamental level buying one eBook at a time Bell 's theorem and.... Very successful theory that has impacted on many areas of physics, from pure theory to applications If think! The ontology of the best known textbooks on advanced quantum mechanics. a starting point is to acknowledge understanding! Model known as quantum electrodynamics ( QED ) to your door, 1996-2021! Read reviews from world ’ s going on inside the device and Kindle books was coined by Max in. Understand quantum mechanics. I wish to primarily discuss the main strategy the author and... Fully quantum model known as quantum electrodynamics ( QED ) you believe that this item violates a copyright – to..., what does he have in mind affirms that Everett Many-worlds interpretation remains non-local lasting relief from your lower. More generally, how can one possibly address all the books, read about the author, J.. By philosophers all along, physicists have always given them a smug look unavailable edition of book!